This gooseberry pie recipe has some of the best pie filling I've ever tasted! It's sweet and tart, just like your Grandma used to make!
Recently, my coworker gave me gooseberries from her Mom's farm. I was THRILLED, but a bit nervous because although I had enjoyed my fair share of gooseberry pies growing up, I had never made one myself! So, I immediately turned to an old family cookbook to find a tried and true gooseberry pie recipe.
I quickly found a recipe from a family member who is famous for her home cooking and thought, "Bingo!" And even better, her pie called for frozen pie crusts! Like most of you, I rarely have the time or patience to make pie crust from scratch, so I focused entirely on making the most delicious gooseberry pie filling possible.
One thing that you may find unusual about this recipe is the addition of egg yolks to the filling. I was hesitant to add them. I thought, is this a typo? Surely, this is an accident. BUT, I trusted the original recipe and I'm so glad that I did. Adding the egg yolks made such a thick and rich filling. Also, you can see that I attempted a lattice, and kind of failed at it. Don't be like me!
But, the pie still tasted wonderful because the filling was PERFECT! I'm so glad that I had enough gooseberries to make two pies; one for my coworker who so kindly gifted the gooseberries to me, and the other for a weekend visit from my parents.
When my Mom took her first bite, she said it was the "best gooseberry pie she had EVER had." And trust me, that's very high praise.
What do Gooseberries taste like?
Gooseberries have a unique flavor that largely depends on how ripe they are. Green gooseberries are not ripe, but they are most often what is used it cooking. Green gooseberries are very tart and tangy.
As gooseberries ripen, they turn purple and the flavor changes to semi-sweet, like a grape.
What does Gooseberry Pie taste like?
A great gooseberry pie is equal parts SWEET and SOUR. The buttery taste of the crust, and the sweetness of the filling help tame the unripe gooseberries sour flavor.
So, have you ever had gooseberry pie? I'd love to hear any memories that you have of this sweet and sour pie!
If you love this recipe, I think you'd also love:
- Blackberry Peach Hand Pies
- Deep Dish Strawberry Pie!
- Easy Caramel Apple Dump Cake
- Pecan Pie Cobbler
- Grandma's Snickerdoodle Cookies No Cream of Tartar
Pie crust topping