Skip to Content

Inside Out Pumpkin Pie Bites

Creamy pumpkin spice pie filling, filled with a crumbly shortbread and pecan cookie! These inside out pumpkin pie bites will WOW your guests this Thanksgiving!

Inside Out Pumpkin Pie 5

It's confession time. I'm so tired of pumpkin spice. I love the flavor just as much as any 30-year old white girl, but it's gone too far. At the store the other day, I saw pumpkin spice hummus and I think it was my breaking point. Can we collectively agree that we've gone off the deep end, and backpedal a bit? Nobody needs pumpkin spice jelly beans. 

Inside Out Pumpkin Pie Bites 2

I think the thing that depresses me most about pumpkin spice EVERYTHING is that for me, it's taking away from the baked goods that have staying power. Pumpkin bars. Pumpkin cake rolls. Pumpkin pie. Pumpkin bread. And all of the creative varieties of these traditional pumpkin desserts. The desserts that make me think of fall, family, Thanksgiving, and tradition. Desserts that you anticipate year round, and pass from generation to generation.

Inside Out Pumpkin Pie Bites 1

So, I've been groaning a bit about pumpkin, but I finally put my big girl pants on and decided to use the can of pureed pumpkin that's been staring at me since early September. I looked through my family cookbook for some inspiration. My sister makes an incredible pumpkin roll, but that felt a little too involved for a Thursday night. My Grandma made a killer pumpkin pie, but again, I didn't feel like making crust that evening. My eyes landed on my cousin's easy pumpkin cake, and I was sold. Her recipe is a dump style cake, with creamy, sweet pumpkin pie filling on the bottom, covered by a crumbly shortbread type crust. It's pretty easy, while still tasting very special.

Inside Out Pumpkin Pie 3

But, I had a wild thought. What if I somehow made these into individual sized desserts? I'm into those right now. They feel more conducive to the type of gatherings we have, and I can easily ship them off to my husband's work, or bring them in for my coworkers without worrying about my baking dishes going M.I.A. So, I mixed up the two layers of her cake recipe, and whipped out my muffin tins. First in, the pumpkin layer. Next, a ball of the crumbly shortbread cookie topping, plopped in the middle with some extra pecans. I threw them in the oven, and crossed my fingers that they wouldn't be a disaster! When they came out, I absolutely devoured the first one, and felt guilty for every being weary of pumpkin spice. SO GOOD! 

Inside Out Pumpkin Pie Bites 4

You'll definitely want to eat these with a fork. They hold together pretty well, but I wouldn't consider them a "hand held" dessert like a cupcake. If you have fancy matching ramekins (4 ounce size), these would be AWESOME  in them. I used cupcake liners because I wanted them to be easily removed from the tin, and don't have small ramekins. I'll definitely be making these inside out pumpkin pie bites for Thanksgiving, so I have about 30 days to find some ramekins that I like. Enjoy! 

Inside Out Pumpkin Pie Bites

Inside Out Pumpkin Pie Bites

Yield: 24

Delicious pumpkin pie filling, filled crumbly pecan shortbread! Super easy and fun personal sized dessert.

Ingredients

For the pumpkin layer

  • 1 and ¼ cup sugar
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 4 eggs
  • 1 can of pumpkin puree (15 ounce)
  • 1 can of evaporated milk (12 ounce)
  • 2.5 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice

For the cookie filling

  • 1 and ¾ sticks butter, melted
  • 1 box of yellow cake mix, dry
  • 1 cup of chopped pecans
  • Chopped pecans, for garnish

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  2. Line muffin tins with cupcake liners.
  3. In a medium mixing bowl, mix together pumpkin layer ingredients.
  4. In another medium mixing bowl, mix together cookie filling.
  5. Spoon 2.5 tablespoons of pumpkin layer into each cupcake liner.
  6. Scoop about 1 tablespoon of cookie filling and form into a ball with your hands. Place into the middle of each cupcake liner.
  7. Bake at 350F degrees for 30-35 minutes until pumpkin layer is firm and cookie filling is JUST starting to brown.
  8. Remove, from oven, sprinkle with additional chopped pecans.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram


Have you ever taken a traditional family recipe and flipped it on it's head? I'd love to hear about it!

If you love this recipe, you'll probably also like my Blackberry Crumble Dump Cake or these awesome Blackberry Peach Hand Pies (notice a theme there?) 🙂 

Inside Out Pumpkin Pie Bites- Creamy Pumpkin Pie filling, filled with a crumbly pecan shortbread! The perfect fun and EASY dessert for Thanksgiving. Recipe by @michelle_goth www.blackberrycooks.com

35+ Thanksgiving Dessert Recipes - The Cards We Drew

Thursday 5th of November 2015

[…] Inside Out Pumpkin Pie Bites from Blackberry Babe […]

Nutmeg Nanny

Friday 30th of October 2015

Since I see soooooo much food everyday the pumpkin spice can get overwhelming - I feel ya! But these little pie bites are perfection!

Michelle

Monday 2nd of November 2015

Totally agree. I feel like I live in images of food! I'm 100% into pumpkin spice baked goods, I think I just need everything else to take a break... :)

Cathy | Lemon Tree Dwelling

Thursday 29th of October 2015

Ha! I hear you! I guess people jump on whatever is selling....and pumpkin spice definitely sells!!! I love your take on it with these pumpkin pie bites - I bet they're delicious :)

Michelle

Thursday 29th of October 2015

They sure do, and I don't really blame them. Just something about that pumpkin spice hummus set me off! :) :)

Erin @ Texanerin Baking

Tuesday 27th of October 2015

Yeees! I wrote about something similar in my post yesterday. I just don't care about pumpkin this year.

And these pumpkin pie bites look so delicious! Especially with that cookie filling. :)

Michelle

Wednesday 28th of October 2015

I'm so glad to hear I'm not alone. I felt like a total weirdo!

Cookin Canuck

Tuesday 27th of October 2015

Individual desserts are definitely the way to go. They're always faster to bake, plus who doesn't love mini things. That being said, I'd probably be tempted to eat two of these.

Michelle

Wednesday 28th of October 2015

That's the truth!

Skip to Recipe